| 2013 Topps Chrome Red Refractor /25 Starlin Castro #84 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $44.36 | $22.68 | | US | 2m |
| 2015 Topps Allen & Ginter's Mini Black Border Starlin Castro #277 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $1.85 | $21.42 | | US | 3m |
| 2019 Panini Prizm Tier Iii Zebra Prizm /99 Starlin Castro #224 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $7.82 | $21.60 | | US | 15m |
| Infinity War, Paperback By Starlin, Jim; Lim, Ron (Ilt), Like New Used, Free ... | | $34.56 | $20.56 | | US | 15m |
| 2010 Bowman Chrome Card Starlin Castro Rookie Chicago Cubs Near Mint # Bdp 4 | | $5.40 | $16.42 | | US | 15m |
| 2012 Topps Season Highlights Wal-Mart Blue Border Starlin Castro Checklist #167 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $1.35 | $21.41 | | US | 25m |
| Among Madmen By Starlin, Jim; Graziunas, Dana by Starlin, Jim; Graziunas, Dana | PB | Good | | $14.07 | $6.44 | | US | 27m |
| 2013 Panini Father's Day Studio Progressions Cyan /5 Starlin Castro #4 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $14.89 | $21.80 | | US | 29m |
| Eerie #101 (1979) Warren B&W Horror Comics Magazine The Rook, Jim Starlin Fine- | | $34.16 | $20.55 | | US | 32m |
| Eerie #80 (1977) Warren B&W Horror Comics Magazine Jim Starlin Story Vg+ | | $34.16 | $20.55 | | US | 32m |
| 2012 Topps Mini Gold /61 Starlin Castro #270 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $4.25 | $21.49 | | US | 35m |
| 2020 Topps Update Gold Parallel /2020 - Pick Your Card | | $4.10 | $17.33 | | US | 35m |
| 2013 Topps Allen & Ginter's Minis Starlin Castro #233 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $1.35 | $21.41 | | US | 36m |
| Unread Infinity Gauntlet Tpb Gn Sc 1992 1St Print 1 -6 Starlin Perez Nm Thanos | | $68.34 | $ | | US | 38m |
| 2013 Topps Mini Starlin Castro #113 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $1.76 | $21.42 | | US | 39m |
| 2014 Topps Gypsy Queen Mini Black /199 Starlin Castro #22 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $4.68 | $21.50 | | US | 41m |
| 2015 Topps Heritage '51 Mini Green Back Starlin Castro #101 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $2.31 | $21.44 | | US | 47m |
| 2014 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor /250 Starlin Castro #61 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $1.52 | $21.41 | | US | 48m |
| 2012 Topps Tribute Blue /199 Starlin Castro #11 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $3.47 | $21.46 | | US | 50m |
| 2013 Topps Opening Day Starlin Castro #54 Fulfilled by COMC - World?s largest consignment service | | $1.35 | $21.41 | | US | 51m |